Top 10 Myths vs. Reality: A Comprehensive Guide to Pool Heating

Top 10 Myths vs. Reality: A Comprehensive Guide to Pool Heating

Pool heating can transform your swimming experience, but common misconceptions often lead to confusion. From the presumed superiority of gas heaters to concerns about maintenance and energy use, myths can cloud your judgment.
To clear the air, we’re here to debunk the top 10 pool heating myths. Whether you’re new to pool ownership or looking to optimise your current setup, this guide will help you make informed decisions for efficient and cost-effective pool heating.

Key Insights

 
  1. Gas Heaters and Costs: While gas heaters are quick to heat a pool, rising gas costs make them less economical than electric heat pumps for regular use.
  2. Electric Heat Pumps: Although they may have higher upfront installation costs, electric heat pumps offer significant long-term savings and efficiency.
  3. Solar Heating Viability: Ideal for sunny regions, solar heating can extend swimming seasons and provide a renewable energy source with minimal ongoing costs.
  4. Pool Covers and Efficiency: Modern pool covers can reduce heat loss by up to 70%, making them an effective tool for energy conservation and heating cost reduction.
  5. Continuous Pool Heating: Pools can be heated continuously, but usage and cost depend on regional climates and personal preferences for water temperature.
  6. Combining Heating Systems: While combining heating systems is possible, it’s often more practical to choose a well-suited single system or use solar to offset costs.
  7. Noise Concerns and Placement: Most pool heat pumps are quieter than air conditioners; appropriate placement can minimise potential noise disturbances.
  8. Solar Heater Maintenance: Solar pool heaters require minimal maintenance, mainly checking panels for debris and leaks seasonally.
  9. Proper Heater Sizing: A heater that matches your pool size and conditions is crucial for efficiency and prevents wasted energy.
  10. Automatic Heaters and Energy Savings: Programmable features in automatic pool heaters optimise energy use by maintaining consistent temperatures without continuous operation.

Table of Contents

Myth 1: Gas pool heaters are the best option.

Many people think gas heaters are the most cost-effective option for heating pools because historically, gas had been cheap. Unfortunately, that isn’t true for today. The cost of gas has risen drastically over the past five years and it simply isn’t the most cost-effective way to heat your pool any more. You’ll get more bang for your buck out of electric heat pump pool heaters.

What’s true: gas heaters may not be economical, but they are fast. You can potentially heat a pool in around four hours using a gas heater, which makes them a flexible option: you can decide you want to swim when the weather’s cool and be in the water within hours.

Myth 2: Electric heat pump pool heaters are expensive.

There are two different types of cost: upfront and ongoing. Electric heat pumps can be slightly more to purchase and install, but long-term you’ll see enormous savings compared to gas heaters. Heat pumps don’t need to generate heat; instead, they use electricity to transfer heat from the air to your pool’s water. You can save even more on your energy costs if you have solar roof panels.

What’s true: Electric heat pumps are the most economical way to heat your pool long-term. You can use them to extend your swimming season anywhere in Australia, or even heat it year-round in warmer climates. It’s cheaper than gas heating and more reliable than a solar heating mat.

Myth 3: Solar heating isn’t a good option for most homes.

Solar heating is a little trickier than other pool heaters because it relies on warm weather and sunshine. You need to check for tall shady trees and the direction the sun travels over your property. Having said that, solar heating works brilliantly in Australia’s northern regions such as Queensland, northern New South Wales, Northern Territory and Western Australia.

What’s true: Solar heating is a great option as long as it suits what you want. You won’t be able to swim all year with solar heating, but you can get some extra swimming weeks in and maintain the temperature of your pool during the swim season. Solar heating is also a completely renewable resource and will cost next to nothing after it’s installed, which is a big tick for many pool owners.

Myth 4: Pool covers are ugly and don’t make a difference.

Pool covers prevent up to 70% heat loss on your pool. That’s actually a huge difference! Many people who install pool heating come back for a cover after their first swim season, because they realise how much heat is lost through evaporation and cooler nights. The less you need to run your heater the more you’ll save on your energy bill.

What’s true: modern pool covers are anything but ugly. They’re easy to manoeuvre and can be attached to spindles for easier removal and a tidy poolside. Covers can be made to fit pools of any size and shape and come in a variety of thicknesses. You can also look at a liquid pool cover to help ward off evaporation, although it won’t stop heat loss.

Myth 5: Pool heating is only for the summer months.

Yes, it’s cheaper to heat your pool in summer while the weather is warmer, but it’s entirely possible to keep it swimmable throughout winter. If you live in a warmer climate it’s an easy task. However, if you live in Tasmania or Victoria where winters are particularly chilly and windy you might find it’s not something you feel like doing even in a pool that’s 32 degrees Celsius!

What’s true: It’s up to you how long you want to run your pool heater. We know people in Queensland who run their pool at a balmy 28 degrees Celsius year-round and love it. It depends on the way you want to use your pool and how much you’re prepared to spend on energy costs.

Myth 6: You can’t mix-and-match pool heating systems.

This one has a ring of truth to it, but only because it makes more sense to stick to one heating system. Technically you could install an electric heat pump and solar heating and use the solar during sunny days, but it makes far more sense to install rooftop solar that can offset the cost of your heat pump and other energy your household uses.

What’s true: You can double up on systems, but it’s probably a better idea to work out which system suits what you need. Remember to ask a professional to help you size up your pool heating system to make sure you’re getting one that can heat your pool properly and economically.

Myth 7: Pool heat pumps are too noisy.

We’ve heard people say electric heat pumps are too noisy to run, but it all depends on the brand and size you choose. Most pumps are much quieter than an air conditioning unit, giving off just enough of a hum to let you know it’s working.

What’s true: You do need to think about the location of the heat pump. If you plan on running it during the day, it might be ok next to the house while everyone is out or being generally noisy. But, if you plan on running it at night it’s a good idea to position it somewhere near the garden or shed. A ventilated pool heater box can help mitigate the hum, too.

Myth 8: Solar Pool Heaters Require Constant Maintenance​

Many potential pool owners hesitate to invest in solar heating systems due to the belief that they require continuous and complicated upkeep. In reality, solar pool heaters have straightforward maintenance needs, often less demanding than other types. Solar heaters primarily consist of durable panels designed to withstand varying weather conditions, reducing the likelihood of frequent repairs.

What’s True: Solar pool heaters are low-maintenance compared to other systems. Basic seasonal tasks, like clearing debris from panels and checking for leaks, are typically all that’s needed. They are a cost-effective, eco-friendly heating choice.

Myth 9: A Larger Heater Will Always Heat the Pool Faster

It’s a common belief that opting for a larger heater will speed up the heating process. However, installing a heater that’s too big for your pool can lead to inefficiencies and increased energy costs. A properly sized heater, tailored to your pool’s specific dimensions and environmental conditions, ensures optimal performance and energy efficiency.

What’s True: The right heater size depends on your pool’s dimensions, climate, and temperature needs. Oversized heaters can waste energy, while properly sized ones provide efficient and effective heating. Consult a professional to find the ideal size.

Myth 10: Automatic Pool Heaters Waste Energy

There’s a misconception that automatic pool heaters unnecessarily consume energy. On the contrary, these heaters are equipped with programmable features that help maintain consistent water temperatures without excessive energy use.

What’s True: Automatic heaters use programmable settings to maintain consistent temperatures, conserving energy by reducing the need for continuous operation. This efficiency can lead to energy savings while keeping your pool ready to use.

One final myth we can’t forget

Lastly, we often hear that people don’t think they’d use their pool outside of summer. So, if your question is, “Will I use my pool in autumn and spring?” we can tell you from our experience and hundreds of customers’ experiences that yes, you will!

Your pool is an enormous investment, and one that deserves to be maximised. Pools are a lifestyle improvement in so many ways; they’re great for your health, happiness and social wellbeing.

If you’re not sure about what type of pool heater would suit your backyard or how much it will cost, you can call our friendly team anytime. We’ll be able to give you a hand over the phone to help you get started.

Share:

On Key

Related Posts

Is pool heating worth it in winter?

As temperatures drop, many pool owners wonder whether it’s worth keeping their pools warm during winter. While some see swimming as a strictly summer activity,

Scroll to Top

Quick Enquiry

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.